Cigar Reviews Archives | CigarScore.com

Cigar Review: Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour Toro

Initial Thoughts: Winston Churchill is one of the most iconic names in the cigar world, and he didn’t even make cigars. His name and profile are practically synonymous with cigars, and today I’m enjoying a cigar that bears his name. The Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour Toro is a beautiful cigar with just a couple of […]

Cigar Review: Nova Cigars Platinum Perfecto

Initial Thoughts: When I pulled the Nova Cigars Platinum Perfecto out of the June box from Luxury Cigar Club, I said to myself, “Ellory, you’ve got to smoke this cigar immediately!” So, spoiler alert, I did. This cigar just looks cool. Like a torpedo missing its fins, this Platinum Perfecto looks like it’s ready to launch […]

Cigar Review: Fratello Navetta Inverso Toro

Initial Thoughts: I can’t tell you how excited I am to smoke the Fratello Navetta Inverso! After discovering the Fratello Navetta Endeavor, which I loved, I put off smoking the Inverso because I didn’t want to risk damaging the wonderful memory of past smokes. However, as soon as I lit the Inverso, all fears were assuaged […]

Cigar Review: Liga Privada Nasty Fritas

Initial Thoughts: Just like not all cigars are created equal, not all cigars are shaped like a tube. And that is definitely the case of this Liga Privada Nasty Fritas. This weird looking, oddly shaped, turd-reminiscient cigar has a dark, brown wrapper that is fairly rustic in appearance. The closed foot is very exciting and a […]

Cigar Review: CAO Flathead V660

Initial Thoughts: The CAO Flathead V660 is one of the highest rated, larger ring gauge cigars in the world. In fact, it won the #3 slot for Cigar of the Year by Cigar Aficionado in 2015. In the years since, I’ve been hoping to grab one of these sticks to enjoy, and today I get to. […]

Cigar Review: Davidoff 6th Avenue

Initial Thoughts: I love finding rare and exclusive cigars. So, when I walked into the Davidoff store on Madison Avenue in New York, I had to buy a cigar that only they sold, the Davidoff 6th Avenue. I’m pretty excited to smoke this cigar. At the time I wrote this review and recorded the video below, […]

Cigar Review: Perdomo Champagne Robusto

Initial Thoughts: I first heard about the Perdomo Champagne when we were in Rockford, Illinois. Mike, the owner of Rudy’s Cigars, told me about this cigar, but I was hesitant to try it because of the cigar’s light color. The Perdomo Champagne, a.k.a. Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Cabinet Series Champagne is an interesting cigar. Nick Perdomo, […]

Cigar Review: Padron 1964 Anniversary Series

Initial Thoughts: Padron is one of the biggest names in the cigar world, and the Padron 1964 Anniversary Series is one of their most famous cigars. In the past, Padron cigars haven’t been my favorite. I’ve always felt like they tasted like dirt (the correct terminology would be “earthy”), so I’ve stayed away. But, given the […]

Cigar Review: Montecristo Nicaragua Series Toro

Initial Thoughts: The Montecristo name is almost synonymous with cigars. They’ve been making cigars for decades, and they’re one of the biggest names in the cigar game. Although I’ve not smoked many Montecristo cigars in my day, when I saw the Montecristo Nicaragua Series on the shelf, I knew I had to try it. The cigar […]

Cigar Review: Muestra de Saka Nacatamale by Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust

Initial Thoughts: Very few people in the cigar world make a name for themselves outside the brand they’re associated with. Of course, the Fuente family members have an advantage, but if you’re not from a Cuban family with 100+ years of cigar heritage, establishing yourself can be a challenge. However, Steve Saka has done it. And, […]

1 2 3 … 10 Next »

Archive

On this page, you’ll find our cigar reviews. Each cigar is scored from 1 to 5, with 5 being the best rating possible. After smoking each cigar, that cigar gets a “Cigar Score.” You can read more about our scoring system here.