Cigar Reviews Archives | CigarScore.com

Cigar Review: Sinistro The Last Cowboy Salomon

Initial Thoughts: I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again – I love cigar subscription boxes because I get to taste cigars I might never buy for myself. That said, when someone else is picking out your smoke, well… you might end up with something you don’t love. Whatever your reasons, check out Luxury Cigar […]

Cigar Review: The Tabernacle Lancero by Foundation Cigar Co.

Initial Thoughts: After smoking and reviewing The Tabernacle Toro (which earned a CigarScore of 4), I went into this Lancero with a great deal of excitement. I’m not too familiar with lanceros, they’re just not a size that I’ve smoked a lot, so I had some questions about the burn and draw of a cigar of […]

Cigar Review: Tatuaje TAA 51st

Initial Thoughts: I walked into my local shop and asked if they had anything brand new. “Yep, we sure do!” said the sales rep. And he pulled out a box of Tatuaje TAA 51st robustos. These cigars are meant to commemorate the 51st anniversary of the Tobacconists’ Association of America, and they feature a Nicaraguan filler […]

Cigar Review: Sinistro Mr. White Belicoso

Initial Thoughts: I went into the Sinistro Mr. White completely blind. I knew nothing about this cigar or the Sinistro brand, so this is a totally raw cigar review. After cutting the pyramid tip, I got a decent cold draw, but once I lit the cigar, things tightened up a little bit. I had to cut […]

Cigar Review: Plasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion V

Initial Thoughts: When I first saw the Plasencia Alma Fuerte Generacion V at my local cigar shop, I thought to myself, “Oh, now that looks cool!” The Alma Fuerte is a big cigar with an odd shape that comes in a very unique box. The pyramid shape has an almost pigtail foot that widens into a […]

Cigar Review: Sin Compromiso Seleccion No. 7

Initial Thoughts: When visiting 2 Guys Smoke Shop in Salem, New Hampshire, I asked one of the sales reps what their favorite cigar was. He immediately took me to the Sin Compromiso Seleccion No. 7. At first glance, the Seleccion No. 7 is a big cigar. It’s 7 inches long with a 56 ring gauge. The […]

Cigar Review: Zino Platinum Crown Series Barrel

Initial Thoughts: Zino Davidoff is one of the most famous cigar makers in the world, and the Zino Platinum brand is synonymous with luxury cigars. So, when Luxury Cigar Club sent me a Zino Platinum Crown Series Barrel to smoke, I kept it in my humidor and waited. A perfect (I hope) cigar begs for perfect […]

Cigar Review: Cohiba Black Robusto Tubo

Initial Thoughts: After taking the first puff, I realized that the Cohiba Black Robusto Tubo, despite its near-black wrapper, was actually a medium bodied cigar. When I cut the end cap with my guillotine, tobaccos much lighter in color were revealed inside. The wrapper did have some texture to it, but the cigar was easy to […]

Cigar Review: 1502 Blue Sapphire

Initial Thoughts: I received the 1502 Blue Sapphire as part of my platinum subscription to the Luxury Cigar Club, and when I found out this cigar was a Nicaraguan puro, I was pretty excited. With tobaccos from Esteli, Condega, and Jalapa, Nicaragua, the 1502 Blue Sapphire is a cigar that is full of flavor and immediately […]

Cigar Review: The Judge Toro Fino by My Father

Initial Thoughts: If you’ve been following me for a while, you know I’m a big fan of Don Pepin and My Father Cigars. So, when I picked up The Judge by My Father, I was pretty excited for my next taste of what the Garcia family can do. The Judge is a well-made cigar. The wrapper […]

1 2 3 … 7 Next »

Archive

On this page, you’ll find our cigar reviews. Each cigar is scored from 1 to 5, with 5 being the best rating possible. After smoking each cigar, that cigar gets a “Cigar Score.” You can read more about our scoring system here.