Cigar Reviews Archives | CigarScore.com

Cigar Review: RoMa Craft Aquitaine EMH Saber Tooth

Initial Thoughts: Cigar friends are the best friends, and today I’m smoking a cigar gifted to me by my friend Paul. This is RoMa Craft Aquitaine EMH Saber Tooth, and if it’s like most of the other RoMa Craft cigars I’ve had, it’s sure to knock my socks off! After punching the end of the cigar […]

Cigar Review: Diamond Crown Robusto No. 5

Initial Thoughts: The Diamond Crown line of cigars from JC Newman are some of the most luxurious cigars around. As my friends over at Famous-Smoke say it, “these aromatic cigars are expertly handcrafted by Tabacalera A. Fuente and Newman families using only the rarest tobaccos and double-fermented Connecticut Shade-grown or Broadleaf Maduro wrappers.” It’s hard to […]

Cigar Review: Zino Platinum Scepter Grand Master Robusto

Initial Thoughts: At the time I smoked and reviewed my first Zino Platinum, the Crown Series Barrel, I’d never smoked a cigar so expensive, so light in color, or, perhaps even so luxurious. So, when a friend brought over a 7-10 year old Zino Platinum Scepter Grand Master Robusto to enjoy, I was pretty stoked. On […]

Cigar Review: JC Newman Brick House Natural Robusto

Initial Thoughts: The JC Newman Brick House Robusto is a tribute to the founder of JC Newman Cigars, Julius Caesar Newman. While the previous Brick House cigar wasn’t my favorite, perhaps I got a bad stick, and this one will be better. If you’re ready to join me on this tour of optimism, let’s dive in! […]

Cigar Review: Joya de Nicaragua Joya Silver Toro

Initial Thoughts: When I saw the Joya de Nicaragua Joya Silver at my local lounge, I knew I wanted to review it. After smoking, enjoying, and reviewing other JDN cigars, I decided the Joya Silver was getting added to the list, and I bought it in January 2020 (I know because I stuck a CigarScore Cigar […]

Cigar Review: PSyKO Seven Nicaragua Robusto by Ventura Cigars

Initial Thoughts: One of the best things about joining a cigar of the month club like CIGRco, Luxury Cigar Club, or Good Cigar Co, is that you get access to new and different cigars each month. And that’s the case with today’s cigar, the PSyKO Seven Nicaragua, that I received from CIGRco in September 2019. This […]

cigar review aj fernandez last call habano thumbnail

Cigar Review: AJ Fernandez Last Call Habano Geniales

Initial Thoughts: After trying the Last Call Maduro, I knew I also wanted to try the AJ Fernandez Last Call Habano. This cigar just looks great! The Last Call Habano comes from the AJ Fernandez factory in Nicaragua. It’s short and stout, and it’s a great looking cigar. Compared to the Maduro, the Habano has a […]

Cigar Review: Espinosa Red River Valley Toro

Initial Thoughts: Another gift from a fellow cigar smoker, the Espinosa Red River Valley Toro is a cigar made exclusively for the Texas and Oklahoma cigar markets. The 6 x 50 toro has a dark Mexican San Andres wrapper and Nicaraguan binder and filler tobacco. After cutting the end, the draw is perfectly loose. The initial […]

cigar review cle corojo honduran flavor bomb

Cigar Review: C.L.E. Corojo Robusto

Initial Thoughts: Back when we were living in Boston in 2019, I remember grabbing up the C.L.E Prieto. It was so enjoyable. The flavors were unique and the cigar left a lasting impression with me, so much so that it earned a spot in the list of Best Cigars of 2019. So, when I walked into […]

Cigar Review: Zeal Cigars Got Your Six Gordo

Initial Thoughts: Not every cigar shop has house blends, but some do. So when Bradley Reith over at Zeal Cigars in Phoenix, Arizona asked me to review some of his house blend cigars, I said, “I’m in!” Today’s smoke is a blend Bradley made himself. It’s the Zeal Cigars Got Your Six Gordo, and it’s a […]

Cigar Review: Pospiech Powstanie Broadleaf Belicoso

Initial Thoughts: As soon as I picked up the Powstanie Broadleaf Belicoso, I could smell the dark, rich tobaccos inside. After toasting the foot, the aroma was of chocolate, leather and a hint of floral notes. And, after snipping the end with my guillotine, the draw was perfect. The Powstanie Broadleaf Belicoso comes out of the […]

Cigar Review: AJ Fernandez Last Call Maduro Geniales

Initial Thoughts: Sometimes a cigar sounds great, but you don’t have a lot of time. That’s the situation I found myself in the other day when I first found the AJ Fernandez Last Call Maduro. I didn’t have my order of CigarScore hoodies in yet, so I didn’t have warm clothes for smoking in. So, I […]

Cigar Review: Back2Back Connecticut Toro Gordo

Initial Thoughts: This cigar is YUUUGE! Ok, it’s not that big, but this Back2Back Connecticut is a 6 x 60 Toro Gordo of sorts, and it feels like a big, beefy cigar. While punching the cigar, I accidentally knicked the side of the cigar with the bottom of my lighter (the punch is on the bottom). I […]

Cigar Review: Byron Petit Poemas

Initial Thoughts: My first thought of the Byron Petit Poemas was, Holy crap, this cigar is tiny and it costs $20?! Cigar smokers are honest folk who like holding onto their hard-earned money, so when United Cigars wants to sell me a stick of tobacco for twenty-bucks, I think it should be good. That said, the […]

Cigar Review: Diamond Crown Julius Caesar Robusto

Initial Thoughts: This is the second time a Diamond Crown Julius Caesar cigar has shown up in our reviews. The first time was when we reviewed the Diamond Crown Julius Caesar Toro, but that was back in February of 2019 and before we started CigarScore TV. So, today, we’re diving into the Diamond Crown Julius Caesar […]

1 2 3 … 13 Next »

Archive

On this page, you’ll find our cigar reviews. Each cigar is scored from 1 to 5, with 5 being the best rating possible. After smoking each cigar, that cigar gets a “Cigar Score.” You can read more about our scoring system here.