Cigar Reviews Archives | CigarScore.com

Cigar Review: Bandolero Tremendos

CigarScore: Brand: Bandolero Line: Tremendos Size: 5 x 50 Cut: Punch Light: Matches Price: $13.59 Smoked On: March 4, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: The first puff on the Bandolero Tremendos was sweet and leathery, the second and third tasted of dry paper or cardboard. However, after I gave the cigar a few minutes […]

Cigar Review: Liga Privada T52

CigarScore: Brand: Liga Privada Line: T52 Size: 7 x 54 Cut: Punch Light: Matches Price: $17.39 Smoked On: February 28, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: Liga Privada is somewhat of a rare cigar and a brand I’ve only see a few times over the last year or so. They have a higher price point, […]

Cigar Review: Rocky Patel San Andreas Robusto

CigarScore: Brand: Rocky Patel Line: San Andreas Size: 5 1/2 x 50 Cut: Punch Light: Matches Price: $8.60 Smoked On: February 27, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: I’m always excited to smoke a new Rocky Patel, and this San Andreas was no different. The Rocky Patel San Andreas is a dark cigar that starts […]

Cigar Review: JFR Lunatic Habano Short Titan

CigarScore: Brand: JFR Line: Lunatic Size: 4 3/4 x 60 Cut: Punch Light: Matches Price: $__ Smoked On: February 27, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: The first thing I noticed was how well the short, fat JFR Lunatic Short Titan felt in my hand. It’s like a well-made… I don’t know what, but it’s a […]

Cigar Review: Bugatti Scuro

CigarScore: Brand: Bugatti Line: Scuro Size: 5 x 50 Cut: Punch Light: Match-lit cedar Price: $5.25 Smoked On: February 17, 2019 Initial Thoughts: I’m familiar with Bugatti supercars, but I’m unfamiliar with Bugatti’s line of cigars. So, I went into this smoke with a fair amount of skepticism. However, the Bugatti Scuro is well made, and the dark […]

Cigar Review: Fratello Navetta Endeavor

CigarScore: Brand: Fratello Line: Navetta Size: 6 1/4 x 54 Cut: Punch Light: Matches Price: $11.89 Smoked On: February 26, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: The Fratello Navetta starts off like every cigar should – with a smooth, rich, sweet flavor and an easy draw. This is my first Fratello, and based on my initial thoughts […]

Cigar Review: My Father La Opulencia

CigarScore: Brand: My Father Line: La Opulencia Size: 6 x 54 Cut: Punch Light: Torch Price: $15.95 Smoked On: February 17, 2019 Learn About This Cigar Initial Thoughts: It’s no secret that My Father has become one of my favorite cigar brands. Everyone My Father cigar I’ve reviewed has earned a CigarScore of 4 or 5. So, when […]

Cigar Review: Gurkha Heritage

CigarScore: Brand: Gurkha Line: Heritage Size: 6 1/2 x 54 Cut: Punch Light: Torch-lit cedar Price: $15.10 Smoked On: February 16, 2019 Initial Thoughts: I was excited to buy the Gurkha Heritage but went into it with low expectations. Gurkha cigars have not usually been my favorite. However, the Heritage has a great draw and a wonderful […]

Cigar Review: CAO Nicaragua

CigarScore: Brand: CAO Line: Nicaragua Size: 6 x 50 Cut: Punch Light: Torch Price: $9.50 Smoked On: February 16, 2019 Initial Thoughts: The CAO Nicaragua is an incredibly well-made cigar. It might be weird to talk about the construction of a cigar, but there is so much artistry and work that goes into a great smoke. When you […]

Cigar Review: Camacho Coyolar

CigarScore: Brand: Camacho Line: Coyolar Size: 6 x 52 Cut: Punch Light: Torch Price: $12.10 Smoked On: February 14, 2019 Initial Thoughts: When I first pulled the Camacho Coyolar Super Toro out of the plastic, the cigar smelled young (like when it smells or tastes like freshly cut grass). However, as soon as I lit the cigar, all […]

1 2 3 … 5 Next »

Archive

On this page, you’ll find our cigar reviews. Each cigar is scored from 1 to 5, with 5 being the best rating possible. After smoking each cigar, that cigar gets a “Cigar Score.” You can read more about our scoring system here.